Essex Boys Murders: Convictions Under Fresh Review as New Evidence Challenges 1998 Verdicts

The convictions of two men jailed for one of Essex's most notorious triple murders are being examined again by the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), following claims that evidence used in the original prosecution was flawed.

Michael Steele and Jack Whomes were convicted in January 1998 of murdering Tony Tucker, Pat Tate and Craig Rolfe, whose bodies were discovered inside a Range Rover on an isolated farm track in Rettendon, near Chelmsford, in December 1995.

The killings, which became known as the Essex Boys murders, have remained the subject of controversy for almost three decades.

Now, investigators working to challenge the convictions say they have identified evidence that raises serious questions about the original case.

What Happened in Rettendon?

On the morning of 7 December 1995, the bodies of three men were discovered inside a Range Rover on a remote farm track in Rettendon.

Tony Tucker, 38, Pat Tate, 37, and Craig Rolfe, 26, had been shot dead in what became one of Britain's most infamous gangland murder cases.

The three men were associated with Essex's criminal underworld during the 1990s, including the drugs trade and nightclub security.

The murders attracted particular attention because of connections between the victims and the Basildon nightclub Raquels, which had been linked to the ecstasy tablet taken by teenager Leah Betts before her death in November 1995.

Following a major police investigation, Michael Steele and Jack Whomes were convicted of the murders at the Old Bailey in January 1998.

Both received life sentences.

Why Are the Convictions Being Reviewed Again?

The Criminal Cases Review Commission, the independent body responsible for investigating possible miscarriages of justice, has confirmed that applications concerning Steele and Whomes are under review.

The latest examination follows work by former Metropolitan Police detective David McKelvey and other retired investigators, who have spent several years reassessing the evidence.

Their investigation has raised questions about the reliability of the prosecution's principal witness, mobile telephone evidence and whether alternative accounts of the killings were adequately investigated.

The investigators maintain that the convictions are unsafe.

However, those claims have not been accepted by a court, and neither conviction has been overturned.

Questions Over the Original Witness Evidence

A central part of the prosecution's case was the testimony of Darren Nicholls, a criminal associate who told police he had driven Steele and Whomes to and from the murder scene.

Nicholls became a prosecution witness after being arrested in connection with a separate cannabis importation investigation.

His evidence helped secure the convictions.

However, investigators challenging the verdicts argue that aspects of his account conflict with other evidence, including telephone records.

Questions about Nicholls' reliability are not entirely new.

An earlier CCRC investigation identified information suggesting that he had entered into media agreements before the trial, with potential payments linked to its outcome.

The CCRC also identified concerns about the disclosure of those arrangements to the defence.

That investigation resulted in a referral to the Court of Appeal, but the convictions were upheld in February 2006.

Former Detectives Challenge Telephone Evidence

The latest challenge also focuses on mobile telephone records and the movements of those involved on the evening of the murders.

Former detective David McKelvey and his colleagues argue that telephone data conflicts with parts of the prosecution's timeline.

They have also questioned whether all potentially relevant material was properly disclosed or examined during the original investigation.

The investigators say their findings support the possibility that the murders were committed by others.

These remain claims advanced by those challenging the convictions, rather than established findings of the CCRC or the courts.

Previous Appeals Have Failed

The convictions have been challenged repeatedly since 1998.

Appeals in 1999 and 2006 were unsuccessful, while subsequent reviews by the CCRC did not result in the convictions being overturned.

In January 2023, the CCRC concluded that there was no real possibility of the Court of Appeal overturning the convictions on the material then considered.

The current review therefore represents another attempt to have the case reconsidered.

The CCRC can refer a conviction back to the Court of Appeal where it identifies significant new evidence or arguments that meet the statutory test.

It cannot itself overturn a conviction.

What Have Essex Police Said?

Essex Police has consistently defended the original investigation and the resulting convictions.

In statements concerning previous challenges, the force has emphasised that the case has been extensively examined by investigators, the courts and the CCRC.

Police have also said they will cooperate with the commission and consider any new information.

The force's position remains that the original convictions were properly secured and have survived previous legal challenges.

What Happens Next?

The CCRC must determine whether the material submitted provides sufficient grounds to refer either conviction back to the Court of Appeal.

A referral would not automatically overturn the verdicts. It would allow the Court of Appeal to consider whether the convictions are safe.

For now, Steele and Whomes remain convicted of the murders.

The case continues to attract national attention, having inspired numerous books, documentaries and films, including Essex Boys and the Rise of the Footsoldier series.

More than 30 years after the Rettendon killings, questions surrounding the evidence and the identity of those responsible remain at the centre of a long-running legal dispute.

Chelmsford City Hub will follow the CCRC's review and report any significant developments in the case.

Sources